One of the most popular ETFs among investors throughout 2022 was the JPMorgan (NYSE:JPM) Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI), and for a good reason. By the end of the year, JEPI fell by just -3.54% in value, cushioned by its high double-digit dividend yield throughout the year as its actively managed, derivative income strategy paid off in spades.
Thanks to this, the ETF saw unprecedented inflows throughout last year, and currently sits at around $26.5 billion in assets under management, or AUM. According to the ETF Central Screener, this makes JEPI the largest actively managed ETF on the U.S. market as of the present. Just over the last month, JEPI took in around $1 billion worth of inflows.
JEPI's success hasn't gone unnoticed on the institutional side either. On June 1st, 2023, Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) filed a preliminary prospectus to offer a direct JEPI competitor, called the Goldman Sachs U.S. Equity Premium Income ETF (ticker to be determined).
Here's all you need to know about JEPI and how this proposed new ETF will stack up against it.
JEPI explained
JEPI differs from your average covered call ETF in quite a few ways. Firstly, the ETF's stock selection process is actively managed. Instead of replicating a benchmark index like the S&P 500, JEPI employs a proprietary methodology to identify undervalued and less volatile stocks within the S&P 500.
The resulting portfolio of 134 defensive holdings currently leans towards value-oriented, dividend-paying, large-cap stocks in sectors such as consumer staples, finance, healthcare, and industrial. Once again, the process of how JEPI selects these stocks is a bit of a black box.
Furthermore, JEPI uniquely relies on equity-linked notes (ELNs). This reliance stems from the fact that, although JEPI derives income from covered call options on the S&P 500 index, it can't write these options itself as it doesn't hold all the reference S&P 500 stocks completely.
The use of ELNs allows JEPI to synthetically mimic the risks and returns of an out-of-the-money covered call options overlay on the S&P 500 index. This method, however, introduces some counterparty risk - there's a chance that the counterparty for the ELN may default on due payments.
What's notable about JEPI is its very reasonable expense ratio, which currently clocks in at 0.35%. This is significantly lower than covered call ETF competitors from firms like Global X, and very attractive compared to the usual fees charged by actively managed ETFs.
As of June 12th, 2023, JEPI is paying a 30-day SEC yield of 8.07%, with a 12-month rolling dividend yield of 11.04%. This has been one of the ETF's biggest draws for income-hungry investors.
How Goldman's proposed ETF works
The filing for the Goldman Sachs U.S. Equity Premium Income ETF is fairly bare-bones and doesn't offer a lot of details, but the following can be gleaned:
- The ETF will invest at least 80% of its net assets in equities selected from its benchmark (most likely the S&P 500). However, the ETF is actively managed and will not seek to replicate its benchmark index. Higher portfolio turnover is expected. 20% of the ETF's net assets may be invested in instruments not part of the above.
- The ETF will also invest in FLexible EXchange® Options (FLEX Options), which allow for greater customization of exercise prices and expiration dates.
- The ETFs strategy is centered around selling call options on a variable percentage of the equity investments' market value in its portfolio, AKA a covered call strategy.
- Each month, the percentage of the options overlay is revised, and it is expected that the ETF will sell call options amounting to between 25% and 75% of the portfolio value.
- Additional income sources may include dividend payments from the ETF's equity investments.
- The goal of the ETF is to produce higher-than-average monthly distributions at a relatively stable rate with performance mirroring the majority of the returns associated with its benchmark.
- The ETF is expected to outperform under certain market conditions due to the options premiums received (high-volatility, rangebound market), but could underperform during bull markets when the underlying portfolio appreciates significantly and is capped by the options sold.
- The ETF is able to take a temporary defensive position to respond to adverse market or political conditions. This means allocating up to 100% of its assets in high-quality U.S. government issued securities or commercial paper.
- From this, we can see that the major differences between JEPI and the proposed Goldman Sachs ETF is a reliance on FLEX Options instead of ELNs and the ability to take a temporary defensive position. The stock selection strategy will also vary as well, but I don't expect Goldman Sachs to disclose their "secret sauce". Regardless, I think this ETF is worth keeping an eye on if it comes to fruition.
This content was originally published by our partners at ETF Central.