On Monday, MicroStrategy Inc . (NASDAQ:MSTR) experienced a notable stock price decline, falling approximately 4.4% from around $422 to $403. This descent, however, did not translate into the expected gains for put option holders, Susquehanna International derivative strategists Christopher Jacobson highlighted. Specifically, the March 400 strike puts, which were bought at Friday's close for approximately $144.40, decreased in value to about $130.95 by Tuesday afternoon. This occurred despite the stock's drop, as a significant pullback in implied volatility from 176% to 155% led to a decrease in the options' value. The decline in volatility resulted in a roughly $17 reduction in the put options' price, overpowering the gains from the stock's movement.
The situation with MicroStrategy's options is a stark illustration of the complex relationship between stock volatility and options pricing. Investors often anticipate that a decline in a stock's price will increase the value of put options, as these are bets against the stock. However, in this instance, the decrease in implied volatility played a more dominant role, resulting in a loss for put option holders even as the underlying stock price fell.
The dynamics of MicroStrategy's options market have been under scrutiny, particularly in high-momentum scenarios where volatility tends to follow the stock price rather than move inversely. This pattern was evident when, despite a substantial rally in MicroStrategy's shares by about 39% from November 11 to November 20, the price of the March 200 puts increased from around $17.50 to $21.50 due to a spike in implied volatility.
For traders and investors utilizing options for directional plays or as a hedge, the price and volatility relationship in MicroStrategy's case serves as a cautionary tale. It demonstrates that the typical expectations of options pricing can be upended, especially in high-volatility environments. This underscores the importance of closely monitoring volatility indicators, as they can significantly impact the profitability of options positions.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.