On Thursday, JPMorgan (NYSE:JPM) reaffirmed its confidence in e.l.f. Beauty (NYSE: NYSE:ELF) shares by maintaining an Overweight rating and a $154.00 price target. This decision follows e.l.f. Beauty's issuance of a press release addressing allegations from short seller Muddy Waters (NYSE:WAT).
The beauty company clarified that they requested confidentiality regarding their customs import data with U.S. Customs and Border Protection earlier in 2024 for competitive reasons, in compliance with applicable regulations. Consequently, the public import data post-February 6, 2024, does not reflect the majority of their actual U.S. imports, which is estimated to be approximately 70% underestimated.
e.l.f. Beauty's statement came in response to claims by Muddy Waters suggesting that the company had been exaggerating its revenues, profits, and inventory levels for the past three fiscal quarters. The short seller based their allegations on a perceived discrepancy between e.l.f. Beauty's reported U.S. sales and its imports from China, from which the company sources 80% of its products.
However, e.l.f. Beauty highlighted that the products that pass through U.S. customs represent around 70% of their sales, which could explain the divergence in the data observed by Muddy Waters.
The allegations by Muddy Waters were primarily focused on the data from the third fiscal quarter of 2024, which ended in September. They claimed a perfect correlation had previously existed between e.l.f. Beauty's U.S. sales and its imports, using this to argue that the company might be inflating its financial figures.
e.l.f. Beauty's early morning press release before market open aimed to refute the short seller's accusations and provide transparency regarding the import data situation. JPMorgan's discussion with e.l.f. Beauty following the release of the statement appears to support the company's explanation and counter the claims made by Muddy Waters.
By reiterating the Overweight rating and price target, JPMorgan signals its belief in the ongoing strength and accuracy of e.l.f. Beauty's reported financials, despite the allegations from the short seller. The firm's stance remains unchanged, indicating confidence in e.l.f. Beauty's performance and growth prospects.
In other recent news, e.l.f. Beauty has consistently shown impressive growth in its earnings, particularly highlighted in its Q2 fiscal 2025 results, marking its 23rd consecutive quarter of net sales growth. The company's robust performance led to an upward revision of its fiscal 2025 outlook.
This growth has been recognized by Piper Sandler, which maintained its Overweight rating on the company, citing recent sales data and confidence in management's capabilities. Similarly, DA Davidson reaffirmed its Buy rating on e.l.f. Beauty, noting the company's robust point-of-sale growth and a promising setup for potential upside in the third fiscal quarter of 2025.
In response to allegations made by Muddy Waters Research, e.l.f. Beauty refuted the claims as baseless, emphasizing that the report is based on incomplete data and flawed assumptions. The company underscored its strong consumption data, reported by independent firms like Nielsen and Circana, as evidence of its sound business practices.
These are just some of the recent developments surrounding e.l.f. Beauty. As always, actual results may vary from these forward-looking statements.
InvestingPro Insights
To provide additional context to e.l.f. Beauty's financial situation, recent data from InvestingPro offers valuable insights. Despite the recent controversy, the company's financials show some impressive metrics. For instance, e.l.f. Beauty boasts a remarkable revenue growth of 59.01% over the last twelve months as of Q2 2025, with revenues reaching $1.22 billion. This aligns with one of the InvestingPro Tips, which notes that analysts anticipate sales growth in the current year.
Moreover, the company's gross profit margin stands at an impressive 71.0%, supporting another InvestingPro Tip highlighting e.l.f. Beauty's impressive gross profit margins. This strong profitability metric could help explain JPMorgan's continued confidence in the company despite recent allegations.
It's worth noting that while e.l.f. Beauty's stock has taken a hit recently, with a 30.05% decline over the past three months, the company's fundamentals appear solid. The company operates with a moderate level of debt and its liquid assets exceed short-term obligations, according to InvestingPro Tips.
For investors seeking a more comprehensive analysis, InvestingPro offers 16 additional tips for e.l.f. Beauty, providing a deeper understanding of the company's financial health and market position.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.